Skip to content

FIA tribunal arguments focusing on ‘the code’

Jun 20, 2013, 12:00 PM EST

Mercedes principal Ross Brawn is seen prior to the hearing at the FIA headquarters in Paris Reuters

As the FIA tribunal surrounding tiregate continues to unfold, the arguments are becoming increasingly heated and passionate, with both Pirelli and Mercedes claiming that they are innocent over the matter. However, just as MotorSportsTalk analyzed the details determining the verdict for the case, such fine points could once again come into play in Paris.

For Mercedes, their argument surrounded the FIA’s sporting regulations which they unquestionably come under. Interestingly, they appeared to pick up on the syntax used; the FIA claim that Mercedes ‘undertook’ the test, whilst Mercedes claim that it was in fact Pirelli who ‘undertook’ the test by asking the team to run at the Circuit de Catalunya. Despite both being in the dock, there appears to be little cohesion or collusion between the two parties – perhaps it is a case of damage limitation? Furthermore, Mercedes argued that Ferrari should be brought back into the investigation, despite the Italian team being acquitted after testing with their 2011 car after the Bahrain Grand Prix.

Pirelli’s argument is also finely poised, with their lawyer claiming: “Pirelli cannot understand the disciplinary action. Pirelli is only acting with the rights it was given by the FIA.

“The claims are unfounded because it has been recognized that Pirelli has not violated the code.”

This ‘code’ that the tire supplier is referring to is the set of FIA Sporting Regulations which all teams must adhere too, but Pirelli’s argument is based on the fact that they do not come under the FIA’s jurisdiction as per the regulations.

A closer look at the regulations suggests a very different story though:

“All drivers, competitors and officials participating in the Championship undertake, on behalf of themselves, their employees, agents and suppliers, to observe all the provisions as supplemented or amended of the International Sporting Code (the Code), the Formula One Technical Regulations (the Technical Regulations) and the present Sporting Regulations together referred to as “the Regulations”.

Pirelli, as a supplier, is therefore required to abide by this code, yet their argument is that they are not under this umbrella.

Interestingly, the example which the Italian tire supplier has chosen to use involves Flavio Briatore’s ban from the sport in the wake of Crashgate in 2009. Briatore was banned from all F1 activities, yet he managed to have this ruling overturned in a Paris court as he was not under the FIA’s jurisdiction, and the Italian supremo now attends many grands prix. The FIA reacted by introducing personnel licenses to the sport, covering this loophole. In this case though, the regulations do seem to be more water-tight.

Similarly, Pirelli and Mercedes are trying to expose flaws in the FIA regulations, and it could well come down to the use of English in making a decision, which is due on Friday after all of the evidence was heard today in Paris.

Latest Posts
  1. Barcelona F1 2nd Test Paddock Notebook – Thursday

    Feb 26, 2015, 4:00 PM EST

    Kvyat 262 Getty Images

    Massa flourishes, McLaren and Mercedes flounder, and Ferrari goes all 50 Shades of Rosso Corsa…

  2. Massa: Williams improving, but still trailing Mercedes

    Feb 26, 2015, 3:00 PM EST

    AUTO-F1-ESP-TEST-WILLIAMS Getty Images

    Brazilian driver still believes that Mercedes has the best car in F1 this year.

  3. Hamilton loses afternoon running due to MGU-K failure

    Feb 26, 2015, 2:00 PM EST

    Hamilton 262a Getty Images

    Briton still manages to finish third on Thursday, but is limited to just 48 laps following the power unit issue.

  4. Sainz Jr. pleased with Toro Rosso upgrades in final test

    Feb 26, 2015, 1:45 PM EST

    AUTO-PRIX-F1-ESP-TEST Getty Images

    F1 rookie happy with the final raft of updates on the STR10 ahead of the first race of the year in Australia.

  5. Carmen Jorda joins Lotus F1 Team as development driver

    Feb 26, 2015, 1:00 PM EST

    © Lotus F1 Team © Lotus F1 Team

    Spanish racer will get a chance to test the E23 Hybrid out on track at least once in 2015.

  6. Massa fastest for Williams as final F1 pre-season test begins

    Feb 26, 2015, 12:01 PM EST

    Massa 262 Getty Images

    Brazilian driver posts the fastest time of testing so far; underpins pace with mighty haul of laps.

  7. Gutierrez excited by possibility of Mexican GP practice run-out

    Feb 26, 2015, 11:00 AM EST

    Ferrari Filming Day Getty Images

    Ferrari reserve driver speaks after completing his first running in the new SF15-T at a filming day in Barcelona.

  8. Hydraulic leak sidelines Button and McLaren once again in Barcelona

    Feb 26, 2015, 10:00 AM EST

    F1 Testing In Barcelona - Day One Getty Images

    More woe for McLaren on day one of the final F1 pre-season test in Barcelona.

  9. Webber: Vettel needed fresh motivation in F1

    Feb 26, 2015, 9:00 AM EST

    Ferrari Filming Day Getty Images

    Ex-Red Bull driver believes that Vettel will be rejuvenated following his move to Ferrari for 2015.

  10. Hulkenberg to debut new Force India on Friday afternoon

    Feb 26, 2015, 8:15 AM EST

    Hulkenberg 262 Getty Images

    The VJM08 will finally make its on-track debut with three days to go in winter testing.

  11. Ron Dennis clears up Alonso crash rumors; confirms he was briefly knocked unconscious but was not concussed

    Feb 26, 2015, 7:27 AM EST

    Alonso 262 Getty Images

    McLaren CEO meets with the media to quash incorrect reports surrounding Alonso’s accident in testing.

  12. DiZinno: The dilemma for Justin Wilson and others, is teams as much as budget

    Feb 25, 2015, 5:13 PM EST

    Shell And Pennzoil Grand Prix Of Houston Getty Images

    Justin Wilson’s offseason plight isn’t only budget-related, but due to a reduced number of available opportunities in IndyCar.

  13. American Brad Hollinger increases stake in Williams up to 10 percent

    Feb 25, 2015, 2:45 PM EST

    Felipe Massa, Valtteri Bottas AP

    Brad Hollinger’s investment in Williams’ ownership moves from 5 to 10 percent.

  14. F1: Lineups thus far for final Barcelona test

    Feb 25, 2015, 2:21 PM EST

    F1 Testing In Barcelona - Day Two Getty Images

    Lineups and running order ahead of this week’s Barcelona test.

  15. Szafnauer: First test focused on tires, Wehrlein evaluation

    Feb 25, 2015, 11:27 AM EST

    PascalFI Getty Images

    What Force India couldn’t gain in car evaluation it could gain in 2015 tire and different driver evaluation last week in Barcelona.

  16. It’s coming March 14: First F1 on NBC promo of the year teases Melbourne (VIDEO)

    Feb 25, 2015, 10:15 AM EST

    Australian F1 Grand Prix - Practice Getty Images

    The Melbourne season opener is a little more than two weeks away.

  17. McLaren confirms Alonso leaves hospital, and is out for final test

    Feb 25, 2015, 8:52 AM EST

    AUTO-F1-ESP-TEST-MCLAREN Getty Images

    Fernando Alonso is out of the hospital after his testing crash last week.

  18. Porsche factory ace Nick Tandy confirmed with KCMG, to make for an even busier season

    Feb 25, 2015, 8:30 AM EST

    Patrick Pilet, Richard Lietz,  Nick Tandy AP

    Nick Tandy will embark on a program of LMP1, LMP2 and GT Le Mans in 2015, with KCMG confirmation in WEC.

  19. Force India officially reveals new VJM08, plans Friday track debut

    Feb 25, 2015, 8:22 AM EST

    Photo: Force India Photo: Force India

    Force India confirms Friday car debut for the new VJM08.

  20. Manor targets Melbourne appearance; announces Will Stevens as first driver

    Feb 25, 2015, 8:10 AM EST

    Motor Racing - Formula One World Championship - Japanese Grand Prix - Preparation Day - Suzuka, Japan

    Manor seeks to make Melbourne race appearance and confirms its first driver.