Skip to content

Dirt, NASCAR, Eldora are big winners after Mudsummer Classic

Jul 25, 2013, 1:15 PM EDT

The CarCash Mudsummer Classic Getty Images

Occasionally, you just need to tip your cap to someone on a job well done.

In this case, a tip of the cap to two parties: NASCAR, for taking a chance on a dirt track race for the first time in 40 years, and to Eldora Speedway, its track president Roger Slack and track owner Tony Stewart.

It looked weird at first glance – the sight of these lumbering, overpowered and under-tired NASCAR Camping World Trucks attempting to “slide job” and ride loose around the top groove of the half-mile oval in Rossburg, Ohio.

But after just a few minutes and few laps, it looked massive, and it looked like a spectacle.

From the sold-out crowd, to the heat race format, to Norm Benning making the feature race after holding on in his last-chance qualifier, to the four-wide tribute start and salute to the fans, to the race itself. It looked like authentic racing without appearing contrived. It wasn’t a crash fest; it was fairly clean. It was three hours of racing action, but it was never three hours of tedium.

In fact, the only disappointment was that it seemed every time the leaders were approaching traffic, a caution flew for debris. Now in all cases, the big pieces of debris were shown, so you can put the “phantom debris caution” theory to rest on this occasion.

Kyle Larson drove the wheels off his truck but race winner Austin Dillon came through the field just as much, in fact more so than the widely accepted wunderkind who has been hailed by many as NASCAR’s next big thing.

The immediate cries on social media and in some reports was for “MORE DIRT RACING!” or something along those lines.

The challenge for NASCAR, and perhaps for other domestic forms of motorsport, is not to lose the unique nature of this first, one-off dirt track NASCAR experience.

Some of racing’s most iconic races are that way because they’re sparse. Because they’re unique. Monaco, Indianapolis and Le Mans are iconic; Kansas, Kentucky and Chicagoland are not.

Over-saturation of a certain kind of racing – the preponderance of 400-mile snooze fests on 1.5-mile ovals as an example – pretty much reduces those races to also-ran, can-miss status because there’s no differentiating one from another.

NASCAR’s most exciting races have tended to occur on slower tracks visited infrequently. Bristol and Martinsville, the two half-mile tracks, are among the most fun to watch, as are the two road course races at Sonoma and Watkins Glen. Eldora fits this bill to a T.

For NASCAR, perhaps one or two more dirt track races in a year could go a long way toward building up enough sustained season-long interest in dirt, but not overdoing it.

The easiest way to get “MORE DIRT RACING” from here is to simply visit your local short track and see the action there. They need the support.

But as for last night, it was an excellent dirt-digging, groundbreaking ceremony for a form of racing that seeks to make a resurgence in the minds and wallets of race fans.

Here’s a few extra takes on the race from AP/Dan Gelston, USA Today’s Jeff Gluck and Sporting News’ Bob Pockrass.

And here are tweets from Denny Hamlin and Jimmie Johnson.

Latest Posts
  1. FIA Formula E field heads to Monaco with a wealth of track experience

    May 6, 2015, 3:47 PM EDT

    MonacoePrixview Getty Images

    Monaco gets a tune-up weekend with FIA Formula E this weekend, and most of the field has past track experience.

  2. NHRA to go ahead with Topeka race May 22-24, despite City Council vote against racetrack purchase

    May 6, 2015, 3:31 PM EDT

    nhra kansas nationals logo

    The NHRA said Wednesday that the Kansas Nationals will go on as scheduled, May 22-24, despite the Topeka City Council voting Tuesday against the purchase of Heartland Park Topeka.

  3. INDYCAR announces updated manufacturer points heading into Indy

    May 6, 2015, 2:05 PM EDT

    Tony Kanaan AP

    Update to various engines for manufacturer points.

  4. Coletti returns to IMS for first time since 2006 this weekend

    May 6, 2015, 12:37 PM EDT

    ColettiBarber Getty Images

    Stefano Coletti returns to a track he won at nearly a decade ago, a rare track he knows in his rookie IndyCar season.

  5. Huertas returns, Dracone back as well for GP of Indy at Coyne

    May 6, 2015, 10:56 AM EDT

    GrumpyCatReturns Getty Images

    Carlos Huertas set for return at Dale Coyne Racing for this weekend’s Angie’s List Grand Prix of Indianapolis.

  6. Pagenaud primed for big month of May with Team Penske

    May 6, 2015, 10:00 AM EDT

    Photo: INDYCAR Photo: INDYCAR

    After a decent start on pace, Simon Pagenaud looks for results to match to kick off the month of May.

  7. New McLaren Honda livery revealed

    May 6, 2015, 9:25 AM EDT

    Photo: McLaren Photo: McLaren

    McLaren’s new darker graphite grey livery is unveiled.

  8. Q&A: IMS President Doug Boles heading into 2015 Month of May, 2016 planning

    May 6, 2015, 9:00 AM EDT

    BolesHiRes AP

    MotorSportsTalk’s Tony DiZinno speaks to Indianapolis Motor Speedway president J. Douglas Boles for an overview on the present plans and the future outlook as IMS rolls into the 2015 Month of May and ahead into 2016.

  9. Fast Facts: Angie’s List Grand Prix of Indianapolis

    May 6, 2015, 8:00 AM EDT

    Ryan Hunter-Reay AP

    Fast facts heading into this weekend’s Angie’s List Grand Prix of Indianapolis, courtesy of IndyCar PR staff.

  10. Justin Wilson looks to make most of Indy rides with Andretti Autosport

    May 5, 2015, 7:49 PM EDT

    justin wilson 2014 Getty Images

    Without a full-time ride for this season, Justin Wilson is happy to be back in a race car and to have a ride for at least the next two races.

  11. On eve of 300th IndyCar start, Helio Castroneves eyes record-tying fourth Indy 500 win

    May 5, 2015, 6:02 PM EDT

    Helio ST PETE 2015 AP AP

    Helio Castroneves hopes to enjoy the appetizer this weekend and then sink his teeth into the main course two weeks later.

  12. NHRA legend John Force turns 66, not slowing down any time soon

    May 5, 2015, 2:03 PM EDT

    (Photo courtesy International Motorsports Hall of Fame) (Photo courtesy International Motorsports Hall of Fame)

    At a time when many people would be embracing retirement, legendary NHRA drag racer John Force just keeps motoring along.

  13. Road America adds new video boards, makes further track investments

    May 4, 2015, 5:18 PM EDT

    Photo: Road America Photo: Road America

    Road America invests millions into some track upgrades for 2015.

  14. Olympic gold medalist Nastia Liukin named grand marshal for 2015 Indianapolis 500

    May 4, 2015, 2:18 PM EDT

    Photo: IMS Photo: IMS

    Nastia Liukin named grand marshal for this year’s Indianapolis 500.

  15. Tequila Patron ESM makes its Ligier JS P2 Honda race debut in Spa (VIDEOS)

    May 4, 2015, 1:33 PM EDT

    Photo: Tequila Patron ESM Photo: Tequila Patron ESM

    Videos from the debut of the new Ligier JS P2 Hondas for Tequila Patron ESM at Spa-Francorchamps this weekend.