Skip to content

Don’t be too quick to judge Tony Stewart, let the experts do their jobs

Aug 10, 2014, 5:52 AM EDT

Tony Stewart fatal crash 8-9-2014 AP

Editor’s note: NBCSports.com’s MotorSportsTalk writer Jerry Bonkowski has spent over 30 years as a sports writer, columnist and editor covering NASCAR and motorsports for USA Today, ESPN.com, Yahoo Sports and now MST. He also wrote this column from the unique perspective of having served more than 20 years as a fully-sworn, state-certified part-time police officer.

In the time span of just a few hours after a horrendous accident, Tony Stewart was charged, convicted and sentenced by many in the court of public opinion following Saturday’s fatal incident involving 20-year-old sprint car driver Kevin Ward Jr.

So-called “experts” inundated Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and other forms of social media, carelessly, recklessly and without any type of evidence throwing around words such as “intentional” and “murder.”

Those are very damning words for an incident that on the surface is an accident until proven otherwise – if it can be proven otherwise, that is.

How can they be so sure that Stewart intentionally struck and ran over Ward, leading to his death, which was confirmed about an hour or so after the incident by Ontario County (N.Y.) sheriff Phillip Povero, according to multiple media reports?

Were those people at the small dirt track just about an hour northwest of Watkins Glen International, site of Sunday’s Cheez-It 355 NASCAR Sprint Cup race?

Even Povero told USA Today that Stewart was “fully cooperative” and that “the incident is not being investigated as a criminal matter.” If the investigating sheriff says it’s not a criminal matter or an intentional attack on the racetrack, how can so many people think otherwise? They base that opinion upon what they’ve heard or read or seen – and sometimes even that isn’t clear-cut enough to make such a serious value judgment as Stewart is being accused by so many.

To me, there are only a few undeniable facts that have emerged from the incident. Everything else is supposition, hyperbole and plain guessing:

* First, there was an on-track incident between Stewart and Ward. Based upon video that captured the incident, it appeared to be nothing more than a typical racing incident that happens hundreds of times each year on everything from Sprint Cup tracks to the smallest grassroots racing dirt tracks.

* Second, again, judging by the video, it appears the area where Stewart allegedly struck Ward was rather dimly lit, not unusual for short tracks such as that.

* Third, if investigating sheriff’s deputies believed Stewart did intentionally strike Ward, would he have been released from custody after fully cooperating with investigators?

* Fourth, do sane, normal and logically thinking individuals really believe a driver of Stewart’s caliber, who has done so much in his career, would throw it all away by intentionally hitting a mere kid on a tiny dirt track in the upstate New York hinterlands? Granted, Stewart has a temper – which has been seen countless times over his career – but would he completely lose control of his sense of right and wrong and go out and murder a kid that he had just spun in a racing incident? Just the thought of that is nothing short of ludicrous.

* Fifth, and this is perhaps the most important part of all: Ward got out of his spun race car. He walked down from the top of the racetrack and into the middle of, again, a dimly-lit area. This is where the true sense of speculation stems. Maybe Stewart didn’t see Ward. Maybe Stewart tried to avoid Ward and it was too late, again, partly due to the lighting in that area of the track and Ward walking down into the middle of the track dressed in a dark firesuit. As much as it pains me to say this, and I’m not attempting to be an “expert” about this event as it unfolded in any way, but what was Ward doing walking around in the middle of a racetrack with cars coming around still under power? That’d be like someone walking in the middle of a freeway to confront someone who he or she just had a fender-bender with. What did Ward try to accomplish by walking directly in front of Stewart, with the likely intent of shaking his fist or pointing a finger at the three-time Sprint Cup champ for spinning him only seconds earlier?

We can’t ever know.

This isn’t the first time a driver has killed someone – and I use the word “killed” in the sense that, yes, a fatality occurred as an end result, but not due to anything intentional on the driver’s part.

NASCAR Hall of Famer Richard Petty struck and killed – again, I’m using that word in context that a death resulted, but it was not from an overt or intentional act upon Petty’s part – an 8-year-old boy during a drag race on Feb. 28, 1965 in Dallas, Ga.

Petty had temporarily left NASCAR racing that season in a dispute over the use of a new and potent 426 Hemi motor that the sanctioning body banned.

With NASCAR still a regional sport based in the Southeast, Petty moved to drag racing, which had caught fire in its Southern California birthplace a decade earlier and progressively moved east and grew into something that was arguably even bigger than NASCAR at the time.

Petty was in a race on that fateful day when something happened to his Plymouth Barracuda. Either something broke or he lost control – or both. Sadly, the end result was Petty’s car left the dragstrip racing surface and plowed into a crowd of fans, killing little Wayne Dye and injuring several other spectators.

After a long and thorough investigation, the accident was ruled just that, and Petty was not charged with any type of offense that stemmed from the crash.

But Petty has carried that memory with him for nearly 50 years. To this day, he still gets upset talking about it, and more often than not simply refuses to discuss it. Stewart is also going to carry the memory of what happened Saturday night with himself as well for the rest of his life.

For now, regardless of what all the “experts” say or media types looking to grab attention with a flashy headline insist, we know only two things for certain:

One, Tony Stewart was involved in an accident, and two, a young man died. Everything else is an unknown until a thorough and proper investigation is performed, no matter how long it takes to complete.

And when that investigation is completed, it will be by trained and REAL experts who will come to a rational and logical conclusion based upon facts and evidence – and not opinion.

As someone once told me many years ago when I first got into journalism, “Opinions without facts are like noses. They both can smell.”

Follow me @JerryBonkowski

Latest Posts
  1. Roger Penske intends to keep his ‘four aces’ in IndyCar

    Jun 29, 2015, 9:29 PM EDT

    roger penske 2015 getty Getty Images

    The 2015 season is the first time Roger Penske has captained four teams on the IndyCar circuit. And it appears it will be full steam ahead with four teams going forward.

  2. Mario Andretti gets Jay Leno up to speed — and then some

    Jun 29, 2015, 8:53 PM EDT

    jay leno mario andretti getty 2015 Getty Images

    Comedian and former late-night talk show host Jay Leno has spent his career making millions laugh. But recently, the joke was on Leno, so to speak – but in a good way.

  3. Racing legend Parnelli Jones featured in upcoming Indy 500 film

    Jun 29, 2015, 8:24 PM EDT

    parnelli jones Getty Images

    If you’re a big fan of the Indianapolis 500 and Indianapolis Motor Speedway, put this on your bucket list for next year.

  4. NHRA: Antron Brown looks to make Top Fuel fireworks this weekend

    Jun 29, 2015, 7:18 PM EDT

    Antron Brown Getty Images

    With five races coming up in the next six weeks, Top Fuel driver Antron Brown knows how crucial this stretch of the NHRA Mello Yello Drag Racing season will be.

  5. Pippa Mann revels in career-best IndyCar finish at Fontana

    Jun 29, 2015, 5:47 PM EDT

    Pippa Mann earned a career-best 13th-place finish in Saturday's MAVTV 500 at Auto Club Speedway. Getty Images

    Finishing 13th in her Dale Coyne Racing Honda, Pippa Mann enjoyed the best showing of her IndyCar career in Saturday’s MAVTV 500 at Auto Club Speedway.

  6. After tough recent outings, Jack Hawksworth relishes 10th-place showing at Fontana

    Jun 29, 2015, 3:37 PM EDT

    jack hawksworth 2015 Fontana getty Getty Images

    Jack Hawksworth enjoyed one of his better runs of 2015 in Saturday’s MAVTV 500 at Auto Club Speedway.

  7. MAVTV 500: Despite being nerve-racking to crazy, drivers glad safety won out

    Jun 29, 2015, 2:20 PM EDT

    briscoe crash fontana 2015 getty Getty Images

    Although it’s been two days since the MAV TV 500, a number of IndyCar drivers are not going to soon forget one of the wildest races the series has seen in a long time.

  8. Senna delighted with fourth in London ePrix after hard battle with Buemi

    Jun 28, 2015, 6:00 PM EDT

    LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 28:  Bruno Senna of Brazil driving for Mahindra Racing during qualifying at Battersea Park Track on June 28, 2015 in London, England.  (Photo by Charles Coates/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Brazilian driver ends the Formula E season with his best finish of fourth.

  9. VisitFlorida.com Racing survives wet weather for Watkins Glen win

    Jun 28, 2015, 5:33 PM EDT

    VF90win Getty Images

    Westbrook and Valiante take their second win of the year at Watkins Glen.

  10. De Silvestro happy with London ePrix weekend, open to more Formula E starts

    Jun 28, 2015, 4:30 PM EDT

    LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 28:  Swiss driver Simona de Silvestro during first practice on the second day of the 2015 FIA Formula E Visa London ePrix Championship at Battersea Park Track on June 28, 2015 in London, England.  (Photo by Charles Coates/Getty Images) Getty Images

    The IndyCar driver finished 11th and 12th in two races at the London ePrix this weekend.

  11. Rahal thanks fans, well-wishers on Twitter after overdue win Saturday

    Jun 28, 2015, 3:10 PM EDT

    RahalTwitter1 Getty Images

    Graham Rahal back on Twitter on Sunday after win on Saturday.

  12. Di Grassi: Formula E title lost with “joke disqualification” in Berlin

    Jun 28, 2015, 3:00 PM EDT

    LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 28:  Championship contender Lucas di Grassi of Brazil during second pracctice on Day two of the 2015 FIA Formula E Visa London ePrix Championship at Battersea Park Track on June 28, 2015 in London, England.  (Photo by Charles Coates/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Brazilian driver remains upbeat despite losing out on the title to bitter rival Nelson Piquet Jr.

  13. Piquet “shocked” by turnaround that led to Formula E championship win

    Jun 28, 2015, 2:00 PM EDT

    Nextev TCRs Brazilian driver Nelson Piquet JR celebrates at the end of the race after winning the inaugural World Championship title after the 2015 FIA Formula E London ePrix championship at Battersea Park in London, England, on June 28, 2015. AFP PHOTO / IAN KINGTON        (Photo credit should read IAN KINGTON/AFP/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Brazilian driver talks about his rise from the midfield to the title across the course of the inaugural Formula E season.

  14. WATCH: IndyCar’s frantic, thrilling MAVTV 500 to re-air at midnight ET on NBCSN

    Jun 28, 2015, 1:36 PM EDT

    MAVTV500replay Getty Images

    Watch a replay of yesterday’s crazy MAVTV 500 from Auto Club Speedway in Fontana either online via NBC Sports Live Extra, or on NBCSN tonight.

  15. Maldonado keen to keep up points streak at Silverstone

    Jun 28, 2015, 1:15 PM EDT

    Lotus F1 Team's Venezuelan driver Pastor Maldonado competes during the qualifying race at the Red Bull Ring in Spielberg on June 20, 2015, ahead of the Austrian Formula One Grand Prix.  AFP PHOTO / ANDREJ ISAKOVIC        (Photo credit should read ANDREJ ISAKOVIC/AFP/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Can the Lotus driver pick up some points for the third straight weekend at the British Grand Prix?

  16. Nelson Piquet Jr crowned first ever FIA Formula E champion in thrilling London finale

    Jun 28, 2015, 11:55 AM EDT

    LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 28:  Championship leader Nelson Piquet jr of Brazil driving for the Nextev TCR team during the second practice session on Day two of the 2015 FIA Formula E Visa London ePrix Championship at Battersea Park Track on June 28, 2015 in London, England.  (Photo by Charles Coates/Getty Images) Getty Images

    The first ever Formula E championship goes right down to the wire in London, but it is Piquet who is crowned champion.

  17. Leimer hopeful of making F1 debut later this year

    Jun 28, 2015, 11:45 AM EDT

    © Manor Marussia F1 Team © Manor Marussia F1 Team

    2013 GP2 Series champion set for practice run-out at Silverstone as part of his reserve role with the team.

  18. MotoGP: Rossi beats Marquez in Dutch TT after last lap clash at Assen

    Jun 28, 2015, 9:30 AM EDT

    Rossi 286 Getty Images

    Rossi extends his lead at the top of the MotoGP championship standings with Dutch TT victory.

  19. Sarrazin takes surprise pole in wet London ePrix qualifying

    Jun 28, 2015, 8:03 AM EDT

    © FIA Formula E © FIA Formula E

    Wet qualifying shakes up the grid ahead of the season finale on Sunday afternoon in London.

  20. DiZinno: IndyCar’s Double-Edged Sword in Fontana

    Jun 28, 2015, 12:12 AM EDT

    DiZacsOpEd Getty Images

    MotorSportsTalk’s Tony DiZinno reflects on one of IndyCar’s most dramatic days in recent memory.